How Much Are Cast Iron Skillets Worth?
A vintage Griswold or Wagner skillet usually sells for $30–$200, while unmarked and modern pans sell for $10–$40 — and a few rare sizes and early marks go for $500 and up. The maker's mark, the size number and whether the pan is flat and crack-free decide the price. Rust is cosmetic; cracks and warps are not.
What decides the value of cast iron skillets
Maker and logo
Griswold (Erie, Pennsylvania, which closed in 1957) and Wagner Ware are the big names. On Griswold, the large-logo and early 'Erie' marks are worth more than the later small-logo pans.
Size
Common sizes (#5 to #10) sell well for cooking. Small and very large sizes — a Griswold #2 or #13 — were made in smaller numbers and are where the collector prices are.
Flat and sound
A pan that spins on a flat surface ('spinner') or rocks is warped, and hairline cracks often hide under rust. Both cut value dramatically — check the bottom and the walls in good light.
Surface
Old pans were machined smooth inside, which buyers love. Rust and old buildup can be stripped and re-seasoned, so they matter less than you'd think; pitting from deep rust does lower value.
Typical price ranges
Broad secondhand-market ranges to orient you — the exact value of your item depends on the precise model, edition and condition. Scan it for the real number.
💡 How FlipTip prices it
Point your camera at the item. FlipTip identifies the exact model, edition and era, checks real listings on your country's marketplaces, and gives you a price range, a sell-speed score and a worth-it-or-skip verdict — before you buy or sell.
Cast Iron Skillets — FAQ
How do I know if my cast iron is a Griswold?
Griswold pans have the Griswold name or cross logo on the bottom with the size number and 'Erie, PA'. Unmarked pans can still be good pans, but buyers pay most for a clear maker's mark.
Should I clean a rusty skillet before selling?
Many collectors prefer to restore pans themselves, and a careless cleaning can do damage. A light cleaning and good photos of the bottom mark and cooking surface are usually enough. Never sell a cracked pan as sound.
What is a 'spinner'?
A pan whose bottom has warped so it spins or rocks on a flat surface. It's a significant flaw that buyers check for, and it lowers the price a lot.
More value guides
Stop guessing at the shelf
Thrift store, garage sale, flea market or your own attic — scan the item and know in seconds if it's a find or a pass.
📸 Scan an item free