What American Girl Dolls Actually Sold For on eBay (2026)
Prices from 76 completed eBay sales between Aug 13, 2026 and Nov 2, 2026. What buyers really paid — not what sellers ask.
Key findings
- American Girl Wicked Elphaba Collector Doll sold for the most: a median of $588 across 16 sales.
- American Girl Truly Me Doll (Loose Modern) was the most affordable of the items tracked, at a median of $65.
- Prices for American Girl Pleasant Company Kirsten Doll spread the most: the middle half sold between $55 and $149 — condition and completeness decide where yours lands.
- American Girl Pleasant Company Kirsten Doll's median rose 317% from October 2026 to November 2026.
- New or sealed American Girl Truly Me Doll (Loose Modern) sold for 146% more than used ones ($145 vs $59 median).
- American Girl Truly Me Doll (Loose Modern) sold most often: 31 tracked sales in the last 30 days.
Sold prices by item
Median = the middle sale. "Middle half" = where the central 50% of sales landed — a realistic range for one in decent condition.
| Item | Median sold price | Middle half | Lowest – highest | Sales | Last 30 days |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| American Girl Wicked Elphaba Collector Doll | $588 | $543 – $640 | $250 – $680 | 16 | 4 |
| American Girl Pleasant Company Kirsten Doll | $101 | $55 – $149 | $44 – $300 | 16 | 16 |
| American Girl Samantha Historical Doll | $100 | $80 – $155 | $40 – $250 | 13 | 12 |
| American Girl Truly Me Doll (Loose Modern) | $65 | $49 – $105 | $30 – $175 | 31 | 31 |
New vs. used
| Item | New / sealed | Used | Difference |
|---|---|---|---|
| American Girl Truly Me Doll (Loose Modern) | $145 (4 sales) | $59 (27 sales) | +146% |
Median by month
Only months with at least 3 sales of an item are shown.
| Item | Aug 2026 | Sep 2026 | Oct 2026 | Nov 2026 |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| American Girl Wicked Elphaba Collector Doll | $629 (3) | $553 (8) | $615 (5) | — |
| American Girl Pleasant Company Kirsten Doll | — | — | $60 (13) | $250 (3) |
| American Girl Samantha Historical Doll | — | — | — | $98 (12) |
| American Girl Truly Me Doll (Loose Modern) | — | — | — | $65 (31) |
📸 Got one in your hands?
Condition, edition and completeness move the price a lot. Scan yours: FlipTip identifies the exact item, shows its latest real sales, your profit after fees and whether it's worth buying. Free plan with 3 scans a day.
Scan an item freeFAQ
How much is American Girl Wicked Elphaba Collector Doll worth?
On eBay, American Girl Wicked Elphaba Collector Doll sold for a median of $588 across 16 completed sales between Aug 13, 2026 and Oct 26, 2026. The middle half sold for $543–$640. Best Offer sales are left out because eBay shows the asking price there, not what was paid.
How much is American Girl Pleasant Company Kirsten Doll worth?
On eBay, American Girl Pleasant Company Kirsten Doll sold for a median of $101 across 16 completed sales between Oct 27, 2026 and Nov 1, 2026. The middle half sold for $55–$149. Best Offer sales are left out because eBay shows the asking price there, not what was paid.
How much is American Girl Samantha Historical Doll worth?
On eBay, American Girl Samantha Historical Doll sold for a median of $100 across 13 completed sales between Sep 26, 2026 and Nov 2, 2026. The middle half sold for $80–$155. Best Offer sales are left out because eBay shows the asking price there, not what was paid.
How much is American Girl Truly Me Doll (Loose Modern) worth?
On eBay, American Girl Truly Me Doll (Loose Modern) sold for a median of $65 across 31 completed sales between Nov 1, 2026 and Nov 2, 2026. The middle half sold for $49–$105. Best Offer sales are left out because eBay shows the asking price there, not what was paid.
How this report is made
- Source: completed sales on eBay.com in US dollars, from Aug 13, 2026 to Nov 2, 2026; new sales are added every month. Prices are the sale price eBay shows, without shipping.
- Only the item itself: each sale's listing is checked to be exactly this item — accessories, parts, lots, graded copies (where noted) and other models are left out.
- Best Offer sales are excluded: eBay shows the asking price on those, not the price that was accepted.
- Mistakes filtered: sales under 30% or over 300% of an item's median are dropped as likely errors or bundles.
- No user data: built only from public eBay sales — never from what FlipTip users scan.
Feel free to quote these numbers with a link to this page. Typical prices and what drives value: American Girl Dolls value guide.